TL;DR: A Manhattan federal judge acquitted brothers Anton and James Peraire-Bueno of wire fraud on November 16, 2026, closing out a case built around a $25 million Ethereum exploit from April 2023. Judge Jessica Clarke ruled that their MEV trading strategy, aggressive as it was, didn’t meet the legal bar for wire fraud because the trades never touched a regulated market. The case had already survived one hung jury and mistrial in November 2025. This ruling ends it for good.

What the judge actually ruled
U.S. District Judge Jessica Clarke didn’t decide whether the Peraire-Bueno brothers behaved ethically. She ruled on a narrower question: did their conduct amount to wire fraud under the specific statute federal prosecutors charged them with. Her answer was no.
According to her written opinion, granting the brothers’ motion for acquittal, prosecutors never showed that the pair made material misrepresentations while executing their trades. Court filings describe how the brothers used what’s been called “bait transactions” designed to manipulate other traders’ automated sandwich bots, intercepting trades meant for someone else. That’s aggressive. It may well be unethical. But Clarke found it doesn’t satisfy the wire fraud statute, partly because the alleged scheme never touched a regulated market, something several federal fraud statutes require as a threshold element.
The distinction carries more weight than it looks like at first glance. Wire fraud convictions typically hinge on deception that causes financial harm through interstate wires or communications. Clarke’s ruling draws a line between a trading strategy that exploits a blockchain’s public, permissionless structure and the kind of deceptive conduct Congress had in mind when it wrote the fraud statutes prosecutors reached for.
How $25 million vanished in about 12 seconds
The underlying incident dates back to April 2023, when a cluster of MEV (maximal extractable value) bots lost more than $25 million in roughly 12 seconds during what reporting at the time called a sophisticated attack on the Ethereum blockchain. MEV itself isn’t exotic or new. It refers to the profit a trader or validator can extract by reordering, inserting, or holding back transactions inside a block, something that happens constantly, and mostly legally, on Ethereum every single day.
What made this incident different was how it was carried out. The Peraire-Bueno brothers, both MIT graduates, allegedly set bait transactions built to trick rival bots running sandwich strategies, a common MEV tactic where a bot wraps a victim’s trade between two of its own to profit from the resulting price movement. Once the competing bots took the bait, the brothers intercepted the transactions and walked away with the funds. Prosecutors described it as a heist. The defense argued it was simply exploiting the same public rules every other MEV bot plays by, just more effectively.
A mistrial, then a three-year wait for an answer
The brothers weren’t arrested until May 2024, more than a year after the exploit, once federal prosecutors in the Southern District of New York said they had pieced together how the pair stole $25 million in roughly 12 seconds. That gap between the exploit and the arrest hinted at how unusual this case was for investigators working through on-chain forensics that even prosecutors struggled to translate for a jury.
The first trial ended in November 2025 with a hung jury and a declared mistrial after deliberations deadlocked. Peter Van Valkenburgh, executive director of Coin Center, called the outcome a “massive overstep” at the time and said the confusion in the jury room wasn’t surprising. “If I wasn’t a crypto person and I was on that jury, I would just be incredibly confused,” he told reporters following the mistrial.
A year later, rather than face a second jury, the case ended on a judge’s motion for acquittal, a mechanism that lets a court throw out charges when prosecutors fail to prove their case as a matter of law, regardless of what a jury might eventually decide. It’s a quieter ending than a retrial, but a far more decisive one for the brothers.

What it means for MEV bots and crypto trading
This ruling doesn’t legalize hacking or outright theft on Ethereum. It draws a narrower line: aggressive, even predatory, trading strategies built entirely out of publicly visible blockchain data and permissionless smart contract behavior aren’t automatically criminal fraud, even when they drain tens of millions of dollars from other traders in seconds.
That line already mattered earlier this month, when traders made roughly $6 million spotting a public code change at BitGo ahead of a Robinhood memecoin listing and trading on it before anyone else noticed. In both cases, the advantage came from information or behavior anyone could technically observe, not from breaking into a system or lying to a counterparty. Regulators and prosecutors are still working out where exploiting that kind of visibility crosses into something a court will actually call fraud.
It also lands at a moment when Ethereum’s own developers are still arguing over how much room the network should leave for this kind of activity in the first place. Vitalik Buterin’s recent push to raise gas costs on state-heavy operations is partly aimed at slowing down exactly the kind of complex, high-frequency transaction patterns MEV bots rely on, even though that debate is about network design rather than criminal law.
Prosecutors haven’t said whether they plan to appeal. Legal observers following the case say an appeal would run into the same core problem Clarke identified in her opinion: proving that a trading strategy which never left the public blockchain amounted to a material misrepresentation under a wire fraud statute written decades before anyone had heard of a smart contract.
The bottom line
Three years after $25 million disappeared from a handful of MEV bots in seconds, the people responsible walked out of a Manhattan courtroom with no conviction and no second trial waiting for them. Judge Clarke’s ruling doesn’t say what the brothers did was right. It says the wire fraud statute prosecutors reached for wasn’t built for a dispute this specific to how Ethereum actually works under the hood. Until Congress or a higher court draws a clearer line, MEV extraction, however aggressive, stays a gray zone that federal prosecutors have now twice failed to turn into a criminal conviction.


